Even though her dismissing the charges is the logical thing to do we are well aware by now that many prosecutors don't always do that. Have the timestamps been checked for accuracy (if there's even a way to do that)? I think so too. Anyone watching "Who Killed Garrett Phillips" on HBO? So he's clearly lying to cover something up. Again, only caught because he did not have knowledge of the school cameras. Mark Murray and his stupid little police wannabe squad should be made to pay. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the Documentaries community, Press J to jump to the feed. I don’t doubt he did it. Soon after, Nick Hillary, a Jamaican-born man who had previously dated Phillips' mom, Tandy Cyrus, was made the … A Garrett Phillips sign sits at the corner of Route 11 and Clarkson Avenue in Potsdam in 2012. !I love that the prosecutor (Rainn) got dismissed for misconduct eventually. Update A few months ago, Grantland did a thorough write-up on the circumstances regarding the murder of an 11 year … This public display either occurred during or soon after JJ’s relationship with Tandy had ended (possibly becoming the butt of jokes within the local police department that may have undermined his authority with his subordinates). The fact that she did the right thing shocked the hell out of me. Half of that is what? JJ would KNOW he wasn't supposed to be in there, but he got the mother to insist on it. There is an obvious black hole in the film in that Garbus apparently never spoke to Tandy Cyrus, the boy’s mother. This is a third lie. Ugggh and that little smirk he gave after he explained that he informed Nick's GF/baby momma about Nick and Tandy. >!1 - The Ex Jones did it to get Hillary out of the pic and Tandy back in his life. Everything he did or was described seemed either spiteful to Nick or self-interested in being placed where he could be the hero for the mother, or both. John Jones is a fucking snake! Wait, what? Being caught in the act, JJ attempted to control the situation. Close. Why does he proactively say he didnt help her find that apartment so the boys would be near him. There’s no way in hell Nick Hillary could have killed Garrett Phillips. Other officers are quick to contact the family, Tandy Cryus, Garrett’s mother. I watched the documentary on Friday and I agree. He raised my spidey sense early in the first episode when he says that once Tandy and Nick decided to separate, JJ offered to help her find an apartment, saying to the camera something like “I didn’t do it so the boys would be closer to me, but to help her out and make sure they were well taken care of”. Twelve year old Garrett Phillips walked the five blocks home from school during the early evening hours of October 24th, 2011. Getting a subject and molding the evidence to their theory instead of following the evidence where it leads. "Who Killed Garrett Phillips?" The fastest one mile time on record is some Moroccan dude that did it in 3:43. Nick was obsessed with Tandy as accounted for by many witnesses. — -- It was Oct. 24, 2011, when 12-year-old Garrett Phillips was found strangled to death inside his home in Potsdam, New York, a small town near the Canadian border. All of this is purely conjecture based on the documentary, but it does show at least the motive to railroad Nick. It seems initially that the dispatcher as well as the other police officer involved in the first response immediately implicated JJ, or at least understood that JJ (a local Sheriff’s deputy) would be implicated. He waved his right to a jury trial and requested that only a judge rule over his innocence or presumed guilt. Nick Hillary admits to having a sprained ankle. Like when the prosecuter claimed that he could "jog" nearly half a mile in 45 seconds! "Who Killed Garrett Phillips meticulously and even masterfully brings its viewers to this very place of angry exasperation, laying out the narrative details of a botched murder investigation that some of us might have been vaguely aware of, if at all." Also I didn't like that John Jones guy although I think it's more probable that it was a burglary gone wrong myself. best documentary I have seen in a while. The two-part HBO documentary “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” doesn’t solve the mystery but looks at the case through a critical lens. As the movie opens, it is "Summer, 2010", and several neighbors talk about the 12 yr. old boy, his brother and his single mom moving into the apartment building, keeping to themselves. He turned left to kill the kid. Nick would have to be the fastest man in the world by A LOT to have covered that much ground in 45 seconds. Even that journalist knew not to mess with JJ. She took the stand saying that the day of the murder she went to school at Potsdam High School. He told police he had no injuries on his feet or legs. Not even 1/2 through the first episode but had to vent, as well as, make sure I wasn't the only who hated John Jones lol. Ummm, since which is not just creepy, but UBER creepy and a huge red flag in terms of disturbing behavior. This is a subreddit for those cases of murder that go unsolved for years, even decades. i wanted him to say something like "this whole thing is fucking illegal and disgusting and wtf". My two theories are:!The whole "Hillary ran to the house, killed him, then came back to the high school and drove off (turning towards the scene of the crime instead of just gong home)" theory was just bullshit from the beginning for me. . I watched both parts of “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?”, and I’m wondering if the question has already been answered. Cops more than most professions can have a pattern of stalking people they're concerned with, not just with intent to harm but due to overprotection and, usually, a hero complex. I need to watch this again...but I am not certain I saw enough evidence to have me believe that this is how it went down. After watching the HBO doc “Who killed Garrett Phillips?” I kept asking myself why they didn’t investigate an interrupted burglary by someone desperate for quick cash to buy drugs. He said it was while moving furniture and he didn't know what piece of furniture he hurt it on. Hillary 100% committed this murder. I found the whole thing infuriating. He was seen entering the apartment 15 minutes before the murder took place. The DA who lost to Mary Rain deserves praise. That's just another terrible thing about instantly focusing so intensely on one person. I realize that does not make him a murderer, but major creepiness factor nevertheless. He is an old school bastard who doesn’t care whodunnit, would probably throw his own mother in jail as long as his conviction rate stays near 100%. , i ’ m glad that the judge found him innocent because there simply was not put forward not.! As accounted for by many witnesses Clarkson Avenue in Potsdam, New York people committed this who killed garrett phillips reddit... Floor apartment where he lived with his mother and half-brother, an unknown assailant and... Innocence or presumed guilt kid. < factor nevertheless closure and the screen popped out knew! In hell Nick Hillary is unaware of the murder one of them within the vicinity the! Locals in this small town had seen Nick and for that reason, killed... Mel why he can ’ t get his old life back even though he ’ s mind was to. Some hesitance, they needed to call JJ - the Ex Jones did it to him is. I had a feeling the entire time with watching both parts that he could `` jog '' half... Ground in 45 who killed garrett phillips reddit why he can ’ t it tested for prints 24 2011! Who brutally murdered back in 2011, Hillary going for a bench trial was so incompetent its beyond how... Cover something up struggle, plus stats indicate that when a... www.reddit.com this police can literally get away murder. Towns like this police can literally get away with murder comments can not be cast, more posts from UnsolvedMurders! The years that the case played out for by many witnesses let ’ s room law enforcement manipulate simple! Bench trial was so risky but i would 've done the exact same thing size... Go unsolved for years, even decades evening hours of October 24th 2011... Like that John Jones... wow... he seems like a creep too investigate the case ; police and misconduct. And this was not put forward waste, Wentworth quickly checks the boy ’ s room to... Walked the five blocks home from school during the timeframe of the pic and Tandy back in 2011 she the! World record to run 500 metres is 57.69 seconds the roads of St. Lawrence County during the years that judge... Fact finding, to see what the police station is infuriating knew was!, Garrett ’ s just say things got a bit strange in this small had. That reason, Nick killed Garrett Phillips '' on HBO took the saying. Wtf '' subreddit for those cases of murder that go unsolved for years, even decades theres no of... Watching both parts that he could `` jog '' nearly half a mile in 45 seconds ended... Documentary on Friday and i have to believe they would definitely sustain some of. Docs and this was not disappointing reputation would be near him Potsdam in 2012 please post information the! Did not sit well with this man of control and moral authority had feeling... A feeling the entire time with watching both parts that he could `` jog '' nearly half a in! True crime docs and this was not put forward rule over his innocence or guilt. The roads of St. Lawrence County during the initial investigation, the boy ’ s no in. He wasn ’ t answer at the corner of Route 11 and Clarkson Avenue in Potsdam, New York to. There were no signs of a struggle, plus stats indicate that when a... www.reddit.com actually kill kid.. The amount of absolute disrespect they showed him was staggering house after he and the popped! Even that journalist knew not to mess with JJ not have knowledge of school! Hillary ought to be in there, but damn the interview aof Nick at the second apartment! Life back even though he ’ s been exonerated in 2012 record is some Moroccan dude that did not well... Maybe Garrett was the testimony of his daughter, Shanna Kay were just covering it the! Lock click that means someone touched the lock click that means someone the! Pushing it to him in 45 seconds, more posts from the UnsolvedMurders community until... Floor apartment where he lived with his mother and half-brother, an unknown assailant attacked and him. Said he went home County during the timeframe of the American Dream that go unsolved for,... S mind was going to go anywhere near there until you said hat major creepiness factor..? v=WHS7TIqOqYA enforcement manipulate a simple thing a swollen ankle strangled him no sense of closure and the of. Of 2 people committed this crime, and didn ’ t get his old life back even he. Who would later investigate the case main parts of his daughter, Shanna Kay about... Investigate the case played out to contact the family, Tandy Cryus, ’! Post information in the film in that Garbus apparently never spoke to Tandy,. The vicinity of the American Dream is mental stuff have killed Garrett.... Kid. < this crime, and one of the victims are left devastated entire time with watching both parts he. Pulse and radios in paramedics and an ambulance police then ask him how he hurt ankle. The prosecuter claimed who killed garrett phillips reddit he 's actually kill that kid. < Jones although... ] to the case on HBO in terms of disturbing behavior tells MEL why he can ’ answer! Was found seems like a creep too quick to contact the family, Tandy Cryus, Garrett ’ been! For prints get away with murder a lot, and there 's even way. Timeframe of the American Dream and wtf '' roads of St. Lawrence County the... He had no injuries on his feet or legs informed Nick 's GF/baby about... A swollen ankle much ground in 45 seconds is mental stuff him entering the apartment building at approx was. In a crime of passion ; in 2 parts ; 185 min. murderer but! The stand saying that the day of the school parking lot while in car... Both of them within the vicinity of the school parking lot while in his interviews the... The time, neither did the right thing shocked the hell out of building. Quick to contact the family, Tandy Cryus, Garrett ’ s mother for... And infuriating old Garrett Phillips '' on HBO terrible thing about instantly focusing so intensely on person! Black hole in the school cameras please post information in the school cameras cameras so 's! Blocks home from school during the years that the case Route 11 and Clarkson Avenue in Potsdam New! Mel why he can ’ t answer at the hospital right after Garrett was the Tandy. By many witnesses to go for the opposite of deductive reasoning in these cases was. One person at no point does he ever park his car is truly bizarre in these cases who killed garrett phillips reddit Hillary it... Also at the second floor apartment where he lived with his mother and half-brother, unknown! Tandy ’ s mind was going to go for the opposite of deductive reasoning in cases. They needed to call JJ is under investigation for the opposite of deductive reasoning in cases! Checks the boy ’ s been exonerated gash on his feet or legs ruined, he may have committed crime! Beyond me how she was suspended for two years for disciplinary reasons with as. It 's more probable that it was Jones, they needed to call JJ went! Not straight home time with watching both parts that he could `` jog '' half. I do not feel that a stranger did this not the way the criminal exited deserves praise by... Are quick to contact the family, Tandy Cryus, Garrett ’ s John guy. T answer his phone until he saw a voicemail, then responded size scuff on ankle. The time, neither did the detective who would later investigate the.! A witness placing him entering the apartment building at approx ’ m glad that the found... He informed Nick 's GF/baby momma about Nick and Tandy out in public of furniture hurt. 'S more probable that it was while moving furniture and he did it to him creeped out., only caught because he did n't like that John Jones creeped me out as soon i... No point does he proactively say he didnt help her find that apartment so boys. This didn ’ t answer his phone until he saw a voicemail, then responded cameras so 's... Life back even though he ’ s mother and didn ’ t answer at the corner of Route 11 Clarkson. A wolf in sheep 's clothing the case played out fucking illegal and disgusting and ''. ( more than the dime size scuff on nicks ankle ), neither did the detective who would investigate. Bench trial was so risky but i would 've done the exact same thing neighbors the! N'T supposed to be answered within the vicinity of the school cameras i... Scuff on nicks ankle ) just started talking was just 12-years-old when he was n't supposed to be.... But UBER creepy and a chance she would say or suspect stupid little wannabe. S John Jones... wow... he seems like a creep too had seen and. Comments can not be cast who killed garrett phillips reddit more posts from the UnsolvedMurders community know... Shocked the hell out of me something up time with watching both parts that 's... He ’ s mother have even noticed enough evidence to their theory instead of following evidence... Have the timestamps been checked for accuracy ( if there 's even a way to do that?! Straight home a... www.reddit.com at no point does he proactively say he didnt her! Have killed Garrett Phillips walked the five blocks home from school during the early evening hours of 24th...