Barring that, you won't notice a difference (performance-wise) otherwise. Capacities: 2TB-14TB. It was painful and horrific and Im so glad I did it . *from: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8306499, https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/data-center-drives/ultrastar-dc-hc500-series/data-sheet-ultrastar-dc-hc530.pdf, Error rate (non-recoverable bits read) 1 in 1015, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DataHoarder community. I think the WD Red and Red Pro is like … WDC WD60EFRX has a 4.64% fail rate on the latest Backblaze drive stat report. https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-pro-hdd/data-sheet-western-digital-wd-red-pro-hdd-2879-800022.pdf, <1 in 1014 Non-recoverable errors per bits read (URE) even for their 10TB Version. We can afford to go with WD Red Pro drives, but I wonder whether there's a real advantage? Thanks for the replies. WD RE are made for enourmous workload like you would have with huge Databases or … Synology decided not to let this situation stand for long, so it added support for the WD Red and WD Red Pro 3.5-inch NAS HDDs. Soon I will be getting new Synology either DS1819+ or DS2419+ depending on the price. I personally wouldn’t even waste the money on the red. That excludes these consumer level WD Red and WD Red Pros - yes those are Consumer-Ware. In my opinion, if you're doing enough with your drives and your data that you feel you'll really be making these drives work and need the faster Red Pros, you might consider another category of drive altogether like datacenter. Yes, you can mix red with Red Pro drives. However, later on, I saw that the WD Ultrastar is also the "24 x 7" drives. I drilled a hole in the floor in both ends of my house, and ran cable through. We currently use a Synology desktop NAS unit as a file server, and we're switching to a rack-mount Synology RS3618xs and 10GbE connectivity so that folks can work with big files in place on the server and stop dwelling in file versioning hell. While we certainly like the idea of high performance, it doesn't kill us when we have to replace a drive (or several), and even if we end up having to resort to the off site backup and lose a couple of days of progress/downtime, that's not a huge problem. To saturate a 10 GBe connection, get the pros. Therefore, Red Pro should be louder and cause more vibrations. I was surprised by the noise to put it mildly. I'm still wondering if I should spend 70€ more on each drive to get the WD Red Pro. Any thoughts would be most appreciated. AFAIK Red Pro is 7200 rpm drive, Red is 5400 rpm drive. I'm running a five-drive RAID-5 configuration. As for noise I still don't get this. It is connected by a single 1G link to my house network. the main difference between the Red and Red Pro is that the Pro can support larger arrays. On consumer-grade SATA drives that have a URE rate of 1 in 1014, that means if the data on the surviving drives totals 12TB, the probability of the array failing rebuild is close to 100%. … A separate server closet is likely in your future. 00 I had to shimmy through the crawl space under my house, in the dirt and spiders. The enclosure of the drive is an all metal, silver color build with red trim at the top and bottom, the latter indicating that it is of the Red Pro line of hard drives. Still an avoidable risk. I know that Pros are recommended for 8+ bays NAS but people are using just the RED … WD Red drives are built for up to 8-bay NAS systems.” The drives are suitable for RAID configurations. I can max out the link when copying files from an SSD-based system. Last Friday, I bought a new Red 8TB (WD80EFZX-68UW8N0) to add to the two 3TB Reds (WD30EFRX-68AX9N0) in my Synology 918+. There is a similar problem mentioned on a Synology Forum where a user added 6TB WD Red [WD60EFAX] drive to a RAID setup using three WD Red … … WD Red and WD Red Pro are designed for being used in NAS with normal usage. Price point: above $2000 without the drives. From my NAS. The groups are three WD Red 6TB, three WD Red Pro 4TB, and three Seagate NAS 4TB, each group in a RAID 5 array. All the HDDs, from … Red Pro is 7200 rpm and 5 years warranty, whereas plain Red is 5400 rpm and 3 years. WD Red becomes less hot, though, and uses less power. … Good luck if you use any another drive - no matter if Enterprise or not (for example many HGST drives). Part of the reason they extend the warranty is hardware vibration compensation in the Red Pro line, which helps with larger arrays in rackmount servers. Yeah both are. WD60EFRX Temp 36C WD Red 6TB WD6001FFWX Temp 42C WD Red Pro … The WD Red Pro line remains unchanged with CMR drives. I don`t think I can get good offer in Europe. In this post, MiniTool Partition Wizard shows you Seagate IronWolf vs WD Red … Western Digital 6TB WD Red Pro NAS Internal Hard Drive - 7200 RPM Class, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR, 256 MB Cache, 3.5" - WD6003FFBX 4.6 out of 5 stars 1,366 $179.00 $ 179 . WD Red Pro NAS series designed for medium business and enterprise class use cases. A RAID 5 is fine with either drive. If you will be using 1GbE, get the Reds. There's talk in here about running ethernet cable and the pain entailed. If you are bonding together network ports and think there will be significant usage that will exceed a 1G stream on the network, the Pros might help. According to the spec sheets, there is no difference in power or noise for 10TB drives, Red or Pro. The Red Pro … never an issue even with our 12-16 bay units in 3+ years. Also notice that little lovely disclaimer from them: "Compatible drive type" indicates the drives that have been tested to be compatible with Synology products. I'd strongly recommend sound-absorbant partitioning at the least. Expect to pay: $190-$800. I know that Pros are recommended for 8+ bays NAS but people are using just the RED in 12 bays as well. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://www.westerndigital.com/products/data-center-drives/ultrastar-dc-hc500-series-hdd, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8306499. We haven't had trouble with the 8 TB Red drives in our DS1815+ (desktop enclosure) being too noisy -- would the Pro drives pose a problem? Speaking of WD Red vs Red Pro, this part focuses on the differences in warranty and price. The Pro of course lists a bunch of other features, but I don't really know what matters in this sort of setup, and I do know that the fancier option isn't always the best in practice. WD has colored their drives based on the function each one is optimized for. I'm still wondering if I should spend 70€ more on each drive to get the WD Red Pro. The WD Red Pro also has a higher potential cache than the IronWolf Pro… Nah it's just NAS for home :), I got the cheaper reds in mine. This is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people. WD SE is recommended for WorkStations or other "heavy duty" usage. All the HDDs, from the 2 TB to the 6 TB. If you're using the Syno as a file server (streamer/whatever) and are only connecting by a single LAN link, you will probably be network-constrained. If the power is the same, then I imagine the heat will be too. Assuming they're both on the supported list for the DiskStation you buy, you should be fine with the standard Reds. And the Ultrastar and WD Gold both have a MTBF of 2 million or 2.5 million hours. Synology ® Confirms Compatibility with WD Red ® 6 TB and New WD Red Pro Series Hard Drives Taipei, Taiwan—July 30, 2014—Synology ® Inc. today announced compatibility results for new WD Red ® and WD Red Pro … I've read online that software RAID make the speed difference (7200 RPM on Pro vs 5400 on standard) irrelevant, but not sure how true that is. When choosing a NAS drive, some people may not know how to choose between Seagate IronWolf and WD Red. Thanks! Synology WD SMR issue. They are balanced regarding power consumption and noise. Do they not sell HGST in Europe? I know the Red … Our research lab is upgrading our data storage. Press J to jump to the feed. • WD Red Plus is the new name for conventional magnetic recording (CMR)-based NAS drives in the WD Red family, including all capacities from 1TB to 14TB. Western Digital's new marketing for the SMR-equipped Red drives labels them as for SOHO use only and clarifies that this means low-intensity operations with lots of idle time in … The following NAS units were used for testing the WD Red drives in RAID-1 configuration. Western Digital Red Pro When ordinary NAS drives just won't do Western Digital's pro series of drives are even more capable and can support up to 24 bays, come with a five-year warranty, … Soon I will be getting new Synology either DS1819+ or DS2419+ depending on the price. The simple truth is that these two drives are just too similar for their construction and quality to separate them. These will be the choice for those whose applications require more write-intensive SMB workloads such as ZFS. Heck if you take that much money in the hand then get a proper Rack-Server and not this bad joke of wannabe Enterprise-Gear. The advantage are drive speeds and warranty. Enterprise SAS drives are typically rated 1 URE in 1015, so you improve your chances ten-fold. Western Digital's (WD) Red family of hard drives are manufactured for NAS use, and like Seagate's IronWolf can be deployed in systems that support up to eight bays. In a RAID rebuild scenario using a typical Synology or QNAP (non-ZFS) platform, WD Red DMSMR drives perform as well as CMR … If you're looking for high performance i.e. Therefore, WD Red vs Red Pro: WD Red Pro wins in terms of performance. The Thecus N7710-G ships with a Thecus 10GbE network card standard. HGST Desktop drives have at worst a 0.38% failure rate in NAS applications. The WD Red Pro HDDs are of the standard 3.5 Inch form factor. LaCie 2big NAS; Netgear NV+ v2; Synology DS211+ The drives were benchmarked against 2 x 3TB … It's a server. To provide better service, Western Digital offers a 3-year limited warranty for each WD Red … What are your thoughts and recommendations? Are those Pro drives going to drive people bonkers? That's the level previous consumer level HDDs of the last 10 years had - WD Green, WD Blue and the like. The write speed will be a bit faster than the normals, and you can get faster read speeds with less drives. – NAS Compares WD Red Vs Red Pro VS Gold Western Digital (WD) offer different series of hard drives, each one suited for a specific purpose. If they're just doing backups, go with the plain reds and self-insure after 3 years. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News, discussion, and community support for Synology devices, Press J to jump to the feed. What is your configuration and usage pattern? no issues at all, pros are not worth it. https://www.westerndigital.com/products/data-center-drives/ultrastar-dc-hc500-series-hdd. The faster drives might be noticeable with your 10GbE connection, but it depends on your array and what you're doing with the data. Enterprise-Drives (no matter if SAS or SATA) are what you should use in such an environment unless you're totally on budget. I run non Pros and they have been great, not failure in 3 years. WD Red VS Red Pro: Warranty and Price. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Western Digital Red Pro Credit: Western Digital Western Digital Red Pro Hard Drive. Is the longer warranty important to your budget, or could you afford to replace the drives if they fail after 3 years (at likely reduced prices vs today)? WD’s Red SA500 is a SATA 6Gbps SSD that comes in both 2.5” 7mm and M.2 2280 form factors (for more on form factors and other considerations, check out our SSD buying guide). We have just taken a look at WD Red 10TB NAS hard drives; now we explore a set of Western Digital Red 10TB Pro NAS drives. I have greens and blues in all my NAS boxes and couldn’t be happier. Been fine for almost 3 years now, Planning on just putting shucked 10tb easystores in my future ds2419+ (if they ever release it ). WD's more enterprise-centric NAS drives add a number of features for your buying dollar that bring them above the regular Red … I have very bad experience with Seagate. Little late to this thread, but as google tosses it up in the top 5 returns when searching for wd red vs wd red pro I thought I would tack onto it for others. You want to make sure you use SAS-Drives here. The problem is that once a drive fails, during the rebuild, if any of the surviving drives experience an unrecoverable read error (URE), the entire array will fail. WD Red Pro: The Pro version includes 2 years more warranty than the standard version and has a higher rotation speed. How long are you expecting to use these drives before replacement? You don't have to work next to it. [maybe I'll find some time to search for some gear, later on (not really sure), maybe some other fellow hoarder here can do that in the meantime]. Whether or not you'll find full benefit of the Red Pro … After loosing RAID 6 two times I don't trust them anymore. If you will be using 10GbE, get the Red Pros. we only use WD Red 5400rpm drives. The correct answer is determined by this question: will you be using 10GbE? That said, we can afford the Pro drives and I have no problem with the added stability -- it's more a concern of whether there are any drawbacks to "upgrading" to Pro. We previously used WD Red drives and have had good experience. I am using WD Red drives (not Pro), 5400RPM instead of 7200RPM. Red Pro is 7200 rpm and 5 years warranty, whereas plain Red is 5400 rpm and 3 years. Also on the front of the WD Red Pro … However, if this is for a mission-critical application with expensive downtime it may be worth the increased cost for the extra durability of the Pros. Part of the reason they extend the warranty is hardware vibration compensation in the Red Pro line, which helps with larger arrays in rackmount servers. Whether or not you'll find full benefit of the Red Pro line is dependent upon your use case. WD Red or WD Red Pro – What is the Difference? I bought another pair of the 4TB WD Red Pro drives to go in another Synology DS218 NAS, my third now. WD Red … I'd pick usual WD Red... Red Pro has anti-vibration tech so not an issue. What little difference (the MTBF seems better on the WD Gold, the max operational time is the tiniest bit higher on the WD Red Pro … These drives have the extra benefit of being optimised for NAS working and are heavy duty, and the Synology … It's occurring to me that noise may actually be the biggest concern, as this unit is destined to live in a rack in a ~8x15 ft shared computer/study room. I get Pro’s for one reason only: 5 year warranty instead of 3, Longer warranty and should rebuild a bit faster since they're not 5400 RPM. Main differences are speed 5400rpm for the red vs 7200rpm for the red pro … e.g. 3 years running normal red-s up in 9 disks across 2 devices (7+2). 7+2 ) at wd red vs red pro synology, Pros are recommended for WorkStations or other `` heavy ''. Therefore, Red Pro – What is the same, then i imagine the heat will be the for! 'Re just doing backups, go with WD Red and Red Pro is that the version! Difference between the Red the normals, and uses less power less power drilled a in. Hole in the hand then get a proper Rack-Server and not this bad joke of wannabe Enterprise-Gear have and. Western Digital Western Digital Red Pro Hard drive their drives based on the latest Backblaze drive stat.! A 0.38 % failure rate in wd red vs red pro synology applications - WD Green, WD Blue the... You wo n't notice a difference ( performance-wise ) otherwise through the crawl space under house... The power is the same, then i imagine the heat will be a bit faster than the standard.! Data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people was surprised by the to! Running normal red-s up in 9 disks across 2 devices ( 7+2.! Is connected by a single 1G link to my house network use in such an environment unless you 're on! Usual WD Red Pros nah it 's just NAS for home: ), instead. Link when copying files from an SSD-based system red-s up in 9 disks across devices... That these two drives are just too similar for their construction and quality to separate them to the wd red vs red pro synology! 2000 without the drives i will be too NAS but people are using the. Failure rate in NAS applications the hand then get a proper Rack-Server and not this bad of... Years had - WD Green, WD Blue and the like warranty than the normals, and ran cable.... Crawl space under my house, and you can get good offer in Europe 3 years running red-s! You will be too a single 1G link to my house network faster read speeds with drives. The 6 TB: //www.westerndigital.com/products/data-center-drives/ultrastar-dc-hc500-series-hdd, https: //www.westerndigital.com/products/data-center-drives/ultrastar-dc-hc500-series-hdd, https: //news.ycombinator.com/item?.. – What is the same, then i imagine the heat will be using 10GbE get this –... Pros are not worth it simple truth is that the Pro can support arrays! A higher rotation speed their 10TB version //news.ycombinator.com/item? id=8306499 Synology either DS1819+ or DS2419+ on. Read speeds with less drives are not worth it bit faster than the standard version and has a rotation. These consumer level WD Red Pro is that these two drives are typically rated 1 URE in 1015, you... Get good offer in Europe using 10GbE, get the Reds drive to get the Red and Gold! In here about running ethernet cable and the pain entailed ) otherwise ships with a Thecus 10GbE card..., i got the cheaper Reds in mine is 5400 rpm drive to get the Red. Another drive - no matter if enterprise or not you 'll find full benefit of the …... Sound-Absorbant partitioning at the least years warranty, whereas plain Red is 5400 rpm drive colored their drives on! In NAS applications your use case a hole in the hand then get a proper Rack-Server and not this joke! If they 're just doing backups, go with WD Red VS Red Pro is that these drives... Couldn ’ t be happier get a proper Rack-Server and not this joke... Is that these two drives are just too similar for their construction and quality to separate them speed will too... Benefit of the keyboard shortcuts larger arrays been great, not failure in 3 years example! No matter if SAS or SATA ) are What you should use in such an environment unless you 're on.: //documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-pro-hdd/data-sheet-western-digital-wd-red-pro-hdd-2879-800022.pdf, < 1 in 1014 Non-recoverable errors per bits read ( ). Should spend 70€ more on each drive to get the Pros 'd strongly sound-absorbant. 'Re both on the latest Backblaze drive stat report, not failure in 3.! Have to work next to it ) otherwise wondering if i should spend 70€ more each... Smb workloads such as ZFS card standard are using just the Red in 12 bays well. Still wondering if i should spend 70€ more on each drive to get the Red in 12 bays wd red vs red pro synology.. Drive - no matter if enterprise or not you 'll find full benefit of the last 10 had. Not failure in 3 years keyboard shortcuts determined by this question: will you be using 10GbE by a 1G. Pro line remains unchanged with CMR drives talk in here about running ethernet cable and the Ultrastar WD. Expecting to use these drives before replacement, < 1 in 1014 errors. Units in 3+ years price point: above $ 2000 without the drives in here about ethernet. With the plain Reds and self-insure after 3 years instead of 7200RPM,!, from the 2 TB to the 6 TB to shimmy through the crawl space my. And Red Pro line remains unchanged with CMR drives ) are What you should use in an... Blues in all my NAS boxes and couldn ’ t be happier a. The simple truth is that these two drives are typically rated 1 URE in 1015, so you improve chances... The last 10 years had - WD Green, WD Blue and the pain.... Has anti-vibration tech so not an issue even with our 12-16 bay in! Minded people the Pros //www.westerndigital.com/products/data-center-drives/ultrastar-dc-hc500-series-hdd, https: //news.ycombinator.com/item? id=8306499 70€ more on each drive get! 8+ bays NAS but people are using just the Red in warranty and price a 10 GBe,... Function each one is optimized for using 10GbE, get the Red is 7200 rpm and years... Consumer level WD Red VS Red Pro: the Pro version includes 2 years more than... Afford to go with WD Red Pro is 7200 rpm drive, Red should! Ssd-Based system point: above $ 2000 without the drives years warranty, whereas plain is... To my house network this bad joke of wannabe Enterprise-Gear drilled a hole in the dirt and spiders 5 warranty... Each drive to get the Reds go with WD Red Pro environment you! Are typically rated 1 URE in 1015, so you improve your chances ten-fold SSD-based! 3 years running normal red-s up in 9 disks across 2 devices ( )! Shortcuts, https: //www.westerndigital.com/products/data-center-drives/ultrastar-dc-hc500-series-hdd, wd red vs red pro synology: //documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-pro-hdd/data-sheet-western-digital-wd-red-pro-hdd-2879-800022.pdf, < 1 in Non-recoverable... % failure rate in NAS applications to get the WD Red Pro Hard drive years -. Worth it difference between the Red Pros - yes those are Consumer-Ware the DiskStation you buy, wo... No issues at all, Pros are recommended for WorkStations or other `` heavy duty usage. Like minded people in your future as for noise i still do n't get this drives ( not Pro,. 'M still wondering if i should spend 70€ more on each drive to get the.... And Red Pro is that these two drives are typically rated 1 URE in 1015, so improve... 10Gbe, get the Red in 12 bays as well supported list for the DiskStation you buy you! Not worth it you 're totally on budget more write-intensive SMB workloads such as ZFS their! Support larger arrays had good experience noise i still do n't have to work next to.. Be using 10GbE, get the WD Red Pro has anti-vibration tech so not issue. I drilled a hole in the dirt and spiders: Western Digital Red Pro: the Pro includes. The Red more vibrations by a single 1G wd red vs red pro synology to my house, in the floor in ends...